A California executive has $3,00,000 in a nonqualified deferred compensation plan. Her distribution election specifies payment upon separation from service. She separates in January 2026. The plan pays out in March, ten weeks after separation. Under §409A, specified employees of publicly traded companies must wait six months after separation before receiving deferred compensation. The March payment is two months premature. California’s 5% additional tax adds $150,000. The violation triggers immediate income inclusion of the amounts required to be included under §409A (in this case, the full $3,000,000 deferred balance) in the year of violation, a 20% additional tax of $600,000 on the included amount, and interest at the underpayment rate plus one percentage point from the date of original deferral. This penalty applies regardless of intent. The plan administrator did not intend a violation. The executive did not. The six-month delay rule is mechanical.
What Is a Section 409A Violation and What Does It Cost?
IRC §409A governs nonqualified deferred compensation, any arrangement that defers income beyond the current tax year and does not qualify as a qualified retirement plan. A §409A violation occurs when the timing of distribution is accelerated, the form of payment is changed impermissibly, or a required six-month delay for specified employees of publicly traded companies is not observed. The cost: immediate income inclusion of the amounts required to be included (which is the full deferred balance for most comprehensive plan violations), a 20% additional tax on the included amount under §409A(a)(1)(B), and interest at the underpayment rate plus 1%. For a California executive, combined federal and California income tax on the included amount, plus the 20% penalty, can consume 70% or more of the deferred balance. The penalty applies to the amount required to be included, which for most full plan violations is the entire balance, but for partial violations affecting only certain plan components may be less.
Who Has This Problem
You are an executive at a California company with any of the following: a nonqualified deferred compensation plan, a supplemental executive retirement plan (SERP), an annual bonus deferral program, a severance plan with delayed payment conditions, or performance stock units or other equity compensation with settlement discretion.
What Section 409A Requires: Three Rules
First: the time and form of payment must be established before the compensation is deferred. An executive cannot elect in December 2026 to change the distribution timing on amounts already deferred before 2026.
Second: distributions may only occur upon six permissible events: separation from service, disability, death, a change in control such as a merger or acquisition, an unforeseeable emergency, or a fixed date specified in advance. Payment triggered by any other event, or payment at a time not specified in the original election, violates §409A.
Third: subsequent deferral elections must be made at least 12 months before the original scheduled payment date and must extend the payment by at least five additional years. Elections that miss the 12-month window or extend by less than five years are void and may cause immediate income inclusion in the year the void election was made.
The Six-Month Delay Rule for Specified Employees of Public Companies
Specified employees of publicly traded companies, generally the top 50 officers by compensation, 5% owners, and 1% owners whose compensation exceeds a threshold indexed for inflation, cannot receive separation-from-service distributions within six months of the separation date. Payment must wait until the first business day of the seventh calendar month following separation, or the date of death if earlier.
This rule applies at every public company on Capital Tax’s client list. A plan document that says only ‘payment upon separation from service’ without the six-month delay language is deficient for specified employees. The deficiency must be corrected before a covered executive separates, not after.
The Four Most Common Violations
Severance Plans With Release Conditions
A severance plan that conditions payment on signing a release of claims creates a §409A timing problem when the release window straddles two tax years. Under Notice 2010-6, as modified by Notice 2010-80, the timing of a release mechanism must not determine the tax year of payment. The plan can pay on a fixed date 60 or 90 days after separation or, whenever the payment period can span two tax years, provide that payment is made in the second year.
Plans without this language allow the executive to inadvertently select the payment year based on when the release is signed, an impermissible modification of the distribution timing.
Discretionary Timing
A plan that gives the company discretion to determine payment timing ‘following separation’ does not specify the time of payment in advance, as §409A requires. Discretionary timing clauses are common in older plan documents and create a §409A violation risk that must be reviewed before any covered executive separates.
Subsequent Deferral Election Errors
An executive who attempts to extend the deferral period on scheduled compensation must act at least 12 months before the original payment date and must push the payment at least five years further out. Elections made after the 12-month window, or that extend payments by fewer than five years, are void. The void election may itself trigger income inclusion in the year it was made.
Equity Arrangements With Settlement Discretion
Performance stock units whose settlement form, stock or cash, is left to the company’s discretion create a §409A exposure if that discretion was not established in the plan document before the compensation was deferred. Settling in one form when the document specifies another triggers §409A. The same principle applies to any stock options tax strategy: settlement and timing terms should be fixed in the plan document before compensation is deferred.
The California Treatment
California generally conforms to the federal §409A framework. California also imposes its own 5% additional tax on the included amount, for a combined 25%. A §409A violation that triggers federal income inclusion triggers California income inclusion in the same year. A California executive who deferred compensation during California employment and receives distributions after relocating to Texas may still owe California income tax on the California-source portion under FTB apportionment principles, a point that should be addressed in any California exit tax plan.
Voluntary Correction Before Discovery
The IRS voluntary correction program under Notice 2010-6 and Notice 2010-80 allows correction of certain §409A documentary and operational failures before they are discovered in an audit. Documentary failures, problems in the plan document itself, have the broadest correction options, sometimes in the same year they are discovered. Operational failures, violations of a plan document that was correctly drafted, have narrower correction options and in most cases cannot be retroactively corrected once the failure has occurred. The program has not been updated since 2010. Its availability for any specific failure should be confirmed with tax counsel before relying on it. If a failure is identified during an IRS examination instead, correction options narrow further and IRS representation becomes part of the response.
What Capital Tax Does
Capital Tax reviews each client’s deferred compensation arrangements for §409A compliance, identifies plan document deficiencies before distributions trigger violations, models California income tax on distributions in the year of receipt as part of ongoing tax planning, and coordinates with employment counsel on corrections. For public company executives, we confirm specified employee status and verify that plan documents include the six-month delay language before any separation.
Begin Your Section 409A Compliance Review
If you are a California executive with a deferred compensation plan, a severance arrangement, or any compensation structure that defers payment beyond the current year, begin your §409A Compliance Review as part of our tax planning for executives. Bring the plan documents, the original deferral elections, and the most recent plan amendment. The review identifies compliance gaps before a distribution triggers the penalty.
Frequently Asked Questions About Section 409A
What Happens If a Deferred Compensation Plan Violates Section 409A?
A Section 409A violation can trigger immediate income inclusion of the affected deferred compensation, a 20% additional federal tax on the included amount, and interest charges. California also imposes an additional 5% tax on the included amount.
How Much Is the Section 409A Penalty?
The federal Section 409A penalty is an additional 20% tax on the amount required to be included in taxable income. California imposes an additional 5% tax, bringing the combined additional tax to 25%, excluding regular income taxes and applicable interest.
Who Is Subject to the Six-Month Delay Rule Under Section 409A?
Specified employees of publicly traded companies must generally wait six months after separation from service before receiving certain deferred compensation distributions. The rule applies to specified employees as defined under Section 409A.
Can an Executive Change a Deferred Compensation Payment Date?
Yes, but subsequent deferral elections must generally be made at least 12 months before the scheduled payment date and must defer payment for at least five additional years, subject to applicable exceptions.
Does California Impose Additional Taxes on Section 409A Violations?
Yes. California imposes an additional 5% tax on the amount included in income due to a Section 409A violation, in addition to the federal 20% additional tax.
Can a Section 409A Violation Be Corrected Before an IRS Audit?
Certain documentary and operational failures may qualify for correction under IRS Notice 2010-6 and Notice 2010-80. However, correction options depend on the type of failure and applicable requirements.
Does Section 409A Apply to Severance Agreements?
Section 409A can apply to severance arrangements that qualify as nonqualified deferred compensation. Payment timing, release conditions, and provisions involving multiple tax years must be structured carefully to avoid compliance issues.
How Can California Executives Avoid Section 409A Penalties?
Executives can reduce compliance risks by reviewing deferred compensation plan documents, confirming distribution elections, checking specified employee status, following the six-month delay rule where applicable, and reviewing subsequent deferral elections.



