100% confidential · No spam
If we assume a 23.8% combined federal rate on the full $1,800,000 gain, you pay this in the year of sale. No deferral. No exclusion. The full appreciated gain is taxed immediately and the remaining $1,571,600 is what you have left to reinvest.
The trust sells the asset tax-free. If we assume the full $2,000,000 is reinvested inside the trust, the donor generates a 20-year income stream on the complete proceeds — not the post-tax remainder. Tax on distributions is deferred and paid as income is received. ¹
| Metric | Standard Sale (23.8% assumed) | CRT Strategy |
|---|---|---|
| Asset Fair Market Value | $2,000,000 | $2,000,000 |
| Cost Basis (assumed) | $200,000 | $200,000 |
| Taxable Gain | $1,800,000 | $0 at transfer ¹ |
| Federal Rate Applied (assumed) | 23.8% (20% LTCG + 3.8% NIIT) ² | Deferred inside trust |
| Immediate Capital Gains Tax | $428,400 ³ | $0 |
| Investable Amount After Tax | $1,571,600 | $2,000,000 |
| 20-Year Income Stream Based On | $1,571,600 (post-tax) | Full $2,000,000 |
| Charitable Income Tax Deduction | None | Partial deduction available ⁴ |
The CRT is almost always the most powerful capital gains deferral strategy available to donors with highly appreciated assets — but it is a structured benefit with strict eligibility rules, not a blanket guarantee. Four scenarios demand careful attention before you rely on it.
Software tools miss this. If the trustee or a disqualified person engages in transactions with the trust — loans, asset sales, or compensation arrangements outside IRS guidelines — the entire trust could lose its tax-exempt status. Requires partner-level structural review before relying on the strategy.
A CRT must pass the IRS 10% remainder test at inception. If the payout rate is too aggressive relative to the trust term and the applicable federal rate (AFR), the trust fails qualification entirely. This requires actuarial modeling at the advisor level — not estimation from an online calculator.
Contributing mortgaged real estate to a CRT triggers Unrelated Business Taxable Income (UBTI), which can compromise the trust's tax-exempt status. The debt must be paid off before contribution or the asset restructured - a step where a real estate CPA can guide the right approach. This is one of the most commonly missed disqualifiers in CRT planning.
The appreciated asset must be contributed to the trust before any binding sale agreement is executed. If a sale is already in progress or a letter of intent has been signed, contributing the asset to a CRT may not defer the capital gains tax. Run the timing with an advisor before assuming eligibility.
Not every asset or donor situation qualifies for a Charitable Remainder Trust. Both the structure and the contributor must meet specific requirements. Here is what you need to know.
CRT Filing Requirements
6 / 6 Complete
Irrevocable Transfer Required
The contribution to a CRT is permanent and irrevocable. You cannot reclaim the asset once it has been transferred into the trust.
Minimum 10% Remainder to Charity
At the time of creation, the actuarial present value of the charitable remainder interest must equal at least 10% of the initial contribution to the trust.
Asset Contributed Before Any Sale Agreement
The appreciated asset must be transferred into the trust before any binding sale agreement is executed. Post-agreement contributions do not qualify for capital gains deferral.
Qualifying Charitable Beneficiary
The remainder must pass to a qualified IRS 501(c)(3) charity. Individuals, non-qualifying entities, and most private foundations do not satisfy this requirement.
Payout Rate Between 5% and 50%
The annual payout rate must fall within the IRS-mandated range and must also satisfy the 10% remainder test. Rates outside this band disqualify the trust at inception.
Individual Donors and Eligible Beneficiaries Only
The income stream may be paid to an individual, trust, or estate. Corporate entities cannot serve as income beneficiaries of a CRT.
| Requirement | Criteria |
| Contribution Type | Irrevocable — cannot be reversed after transfer |
| Charitable Remainder (minimum) | 10% of initial trust value at time of creation |
| Asset Timing | Contributed before any binding sale agreement is executed |
| Qualifying Charity | IRS-recognized 501(c)(3) organization |
| Annual Payout Rate | Between 5% and 50% (must also pass 10% remainder test) |
| Trust Term | Up to 20 years or lifetime of income beneficiary |
| Eligible Beneficiary Type | Individual, trust, or estate — not corporate entities |
Disclaimer: This is not tax advice, and it is recommended to consult a tax professional, as every tax situation is unique.