Schedule A Meeting
Individual Tax · Real Estate Pros

Tax Planning for Realtors & Investors

Commissions arrive with no tax withheld, rentals carry depreciation rules most software misses, and a single property sale can trigger recapture you never saw coming. A strong year in real estate can quietly turn into a tax problem. This page shows realtors and investors how to plan ahead and keep more of what they earn.

Schedule A Meeting


100% confidential · No spam

The Numbers First

How Entity Choice Lowers the Tax Bill

Commission income taxed on a Schedule C carries the full self-employment tax. Routing the same income through an S-corp changes that. Here is the gap on $200,000 of net business income.
Sole Proprietor
Self-Employment Tax

$27,200

On a Schedule C, the full net income is exposed to the 15.3% self-employment tax up to the wage base, then Medicare above it. There is no salary-versus-profit split to soften the hit.

S-Corp Election
Self-Employment Tax

$13,800

Splitting pay into a reasonable salary and distributions is a standard business tax election that keeps payroll tax off the distribution portion of your income.

Metric Sole Proprietor S-Corp Election
Net business income $200,000 $200,000
Reasonable salary (payroll-taxed) — $90,000
Income exposed to SE tax $184,700 $90,000
Self-employment / payroll tax $27,200 $27,200
Annual tax saved — $13,400

Self-Employment Tax Saved

$13,400 a year
Tax Saved = (Net Income − Reasonable Salary) × Payroll Tax Rate, net of added payroll and filing costs. Figures are illustrative.
The CPA View

Four Costly Real Estate Tax Mistakes

These range from quarterly estimate slips to a missing business sale tax strategy when a portfolio or brokerage changes hands. Each one is avoidable with a plan in place before the transaction, not after.

 
⚠ The Estimated-Tax Gap

Commissions Arrive Without Withholding

A 1099 commission has no tax taken out at the source. Skip the quarterly estimates and the full bill, plus an underpayment penalty, lands at filing.
⚠ Overpaying Self-Employment Tax

Staying a Sole Proprietor Too Long

High-earning agents who never revisit their entity keep paying self-employment tax on every dollar of profit, money an S-corp election could have kept.

⚠ Depreciation Recapture

The Bill That Hits at Sale

The depreciation that shielded rental income for years is recaptured when you sell, taxed at up to 25%. Unplanned, it turns a clean sale into a surprise.

⚠ The 1031 Deadline

Missing the 45 and 180-Day Windows

A 1031 exchange can defer the entire gain, but only if a replacement is identified within 45 days and closed within 180. Miss the window and the deferral is gone.

Readiness

Real Estate Tax Readiness Checklist

Run through these before your next closing or tax year. If any item is unclear, it is worth a conversation before the transaction settles.

5 / 5 to be confident

Entity structure reviewed

Schedule C versus S-corp is reassessed against current commission income, not last year’s.
Quarterly estimates scheduled
Estimated payments cover the tax that no employer is withholding from your commissions.
Depreciation and cost segregation captured
Every rental is depreciated correctly, with cost-seg considered on larger properties.
1031 or installment options mapped
Before listing, the deferral and installment routes are modeled so deadlines never catch you.
Real estate professional status checked
If you qualify, passive loss limits can lift, a test worth confirming each year.
Quick Reference
Income type Taxed as Watch for
Commissions Ordinary + SE Quarterly estimates
Rental income Ordinary Passive loss limits
Property sale Capital gain Depreciation recapture
Business sale Mixed Allocation and timing

Build a Smarter Real Estate Tax Strategy

A short review now can save thousands later. We will assess your entity, model the tax on your deals, and build a plan around your transaction calendar.
Schedule A Meeting

Expert FAQs

How are realtors and investors taxed differently?

Realtors are usually independent contractors, so commission income is ordinary income subject to self-employment tax with no withholding. Investors are taxed on rental income and on gains when a property sells, where depreciation, recapture, and capital-gain rates all come into play.
Often, once commission income is high enough to justify a reasonable salary plus distributions. The election shifts part of the profit out of self-employment tax, but it adds payroll and filing costs, so the math should be run before electing.
When you sell a rental, the depreciation deducted over the years is recaptured and taxed, generally at a rate up to 25%. It applies even if the property barely appreciated, which is why it surprises owners who only planned for capital-gains rates.

A 1031 exchange lets you roll the gain from one investment property into a like-kind replacement, deferring tax instead of paying it at sale. The deadlines are strict: 45 days to identify a replacement and 180 days to close.

Many rental activities can qualify for the 20% qualified business income deduction when they rise to the level of a trade or business. Meeting the safe-harbor recordkeeping rules makes the position far easier to support.

Disclaimer: This is not tax advice, and it is recommended to consult a tax professional, as every tax situation is unique.